{ "applicable_version": "0.2.8", "combination_registry": { "not_qualified_combination": null, "records": [ { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-BEAM2-linear_static", "element_family": "BEAM2", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Straight constant-section isotropic small-displacement static BEAM2 only; releases, offsets, plasticity, contact, large rotations and dynamics remain excluded." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP03" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 regression evidence", "0.2.6 case registry: shell_beam_discrete", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 regression and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 modal/dynamic/harmonic coverage is bounded; other BEAM2 scopes remain governed by their own gates. Family-specific requalification is scheduled in G04.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-BEAM2-modal", "element_family": "BEAM2", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Straight slender fixed-root undamped first-two-mode cantilever scope only; thick-beam, damping, joints, offsets and multi-body response remain excluded." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP03" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 regression evidence", "0.2.6 case registry: shell_beam_discrete", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 modal/dynamic/harmonic coverage is bounded; other BEAM2 scopes remain governed by their own gates. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: modal evidence covers eight internal family rows, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "newmark_transient", "capability_id": "COMB-BEAM2-newmark_transient", "element_family": "BEAM2", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "One-element axial UX-only undamped free vibration with the declared Newmark parameters only; no general transient BEAM2 claim." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP03" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 regression evidence", "0.2.6 case registry: shell_beam_discrete", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 modal/dynamic/harmonic coverage is bounded; other BEAM2 scopes remain governed by their own gates. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: Newmark refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "harmonic", "capability_id": "COMB-BEAM2-harmonic", "element_family": "BEAM2", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "One-element axial damped SDOF response on the declared seven-point frequency grid only; no general BEAM2 FRF claim." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP03" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 regression evidence", "0.2.6 case registry: shell_beam_discrete", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 modal/dynamic/harmonic coverage is bounded; other BEAM2 scopes remain governed by their own gates. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: harmonic refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-MITC3-linear_static", "element_family": "MITC3", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Isotropic MITC3 linear static, small-displacement/small-rotation, executed patch, equilibrium, energy, orientation, permutation, thickness and locking scope only.", "Cook, Scordelis and pinched values remain bounded reference trends; composite, nonlinear, contact and dynamic MITC3 remain excluded." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP04" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 READY shell modal/dynamic/harmonic cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 regression and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; no comparable independent external deck is recorded for MITC3. Family-specific requalification is scheduled in G04.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-MITC3-modal", "element_family": "MITC3", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "The inherited same-assembled-model evidence is not sufficient for route-level promotion." ], "owner_decision": "REJECT", "promotion_applied": false, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": "independent executable shell modal oracle", "resulting_maturity": "EXPERIMENTAL", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP04" } ], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 READY shell modal/dynamic/harmonic cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; no comparable independent external deck is recorded for MITC3. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: modal evidence covers eight internal family rows, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "newmark_transient", "capability_id": "COMB-MITC3-newmark_transient", "element_family": "MITC3", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Temporal refinement alone is not accepted as an independent element/oracle qualification." ], "owner_decision": "REJECT", "promotion_applied": false, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": "independent executable same-mesh transient shell oracle", "resulting_maturity": "EXPERIMENTAL", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP04" } ], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 READY shell modal/dynamic/harmonic cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; no comparable independent external deck is recorded for MITC3. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: Newmark refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "harmonic", "capability_id": "COMB-MITC3-harmonic", "element_family": "MITC3", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Internal harmonic evidence does not close the independent shell FRF requirement." ], "owner_decision": "REJECT", "promotion_applied": false, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": "independent executable same-mesh shell FRF oracle", "resulting_maturity": "EXPERIMENTAL", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP04" } ], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 READY shell modal/dynamic/harmonic cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; no comparable independent external deck is recorded for MITC3. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: harmonic refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-MITC4-linear_static", "element_family": "MITC4", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Isotropic constant-thickness MITC4 linear static, small-displacement/small-rotation, executed mechanics, patch, equilibrium, drilling and reference-mesh scope only.", "No variable thickness, composite, nonlinear, contact, buckling or large-rotation claim; Cook remains a bounded trend warning." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP04" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 READY shell modal/dynamic/harmonic cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 regression and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; no comparable independent external deck is recorded for MITC4. Family-specific requalification is scheduled in G04.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-MITC4-modal", "element_family": "MITC4", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "No tolerance relaxation or numerical-core change is authorized." ], "owner_decision": "REJECT", "promotion_applied": false, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": "relative residual", "resulting_maturity": "EXPERIMENTAL", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP04" } ], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 READY shell modal/dynamic/harmonic cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; no comparable independent external deck is recorded for MITC4. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: modal evidence covers eight internal family rows, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "newmark_transient", "capability_id": "COMB-MITC4-newmark_transient", "element_family": "MITC4", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Verified one-mode, undamped free-vibration Newmark average-acceleration temporal scope with the declared 20/40/80 steps-per-period study only.", "The spatial mode is from QF Solver; forced, nonlinear, broadband, composite and curved-dynamic claims remain excluded." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP04" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 READY shell modal/dynamic/harmonic cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; no comparable independent external deck is recorded for MITC4. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: Newmark refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "harmonic", "capability_id": "COMB-MITC4-harmonic", "element_family": "MITC4", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Verified first-mode, seven-frequency, mass-proportional damping FRF scope only.", "Broadband coupling, thick-shell, composite, nonlinear and alternate damping-model claims remain excluded." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP04" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 READY shell modal/dynamic/harmonic cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; no comparable independent external deck is recorded for MITC4. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: harmonic refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-TET4-linear_static", "element_family": "TET4", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 owner evidence", "0.2.6 G05-B TET4 cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 regression and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; external coverage is bounded and other analysis scopes remain separately governed. Family-specific requalification is scheduled in G04.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-TET4-modal", "element_family": "TET4", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 owner evidence", "0.2.6 G05-B TET4 cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; external coverage is bounded and other analysis scopes remain separately governed. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: modal evidence covers eight internal family rows, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "newmark_transient", "capability_id": "COMB-TET4-newmark_transient", "element_family": "TET4", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 owner evidence", "0.2.6 G05-B TET4 cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; external coverage is bounded and other analysis scopes remain separately governed. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: Newmark refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "harmonic", "capability_id": "COMB-TET4-harmonic", "element_family": "TET4", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 owner evidence", "0.2.6 G05-B TET4 cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; external coverage is bounded and other analysis scopes remain separately governed. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: harmonic refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_buckling", "capability_id": "COMB-TET4-linear_buckling", "element_family": "TET4", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 owner evidence", "0.2.6 G05-B TET4 cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 bounded Euler and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; external coverage is bounded and other analysis scopes remain separately governed. No nonlinear collapse claim; 0.2.6 maturity extension is pending.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "nonlinear_load_control", "capability_id": "COMB-TET4-nonlinear_load_control", "element_family": "TET4", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 owner evidence", "0.2.6 G05-B TET4 cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 nonlinear owner evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; external coverage is bounded and other analysis scopes remain separately governed. Maturity extension and multi-family correlation are scheduled separately.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-TET10-linear_static", "element_family": "TET10", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 J2 bounded evidence", "historical modal/dynamic tests", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 regression and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Family-specific requalification is scheduled in G04.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-TET10-modal", "element_family": "TET10", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 J2 bounded evidence", "historical modal/dynamic tests", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: modal evidence covers eight internal family rows, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "newmark_transient", "capability_id": "COMB-TET10-newmark_transient", "element_family": "TET10", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 J2 bounded evidence", "historical modal/dynamic tests", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: Newmark refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "harmonic", "capability_id": "COMB-TET10-harmonic", "element_family": "TET10", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 J2 bounded evidence", "historical modal/dynamic tests", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: harmonic refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_buckling", "capability_id": "COMB-TET10-linear_buckling", "element_family": "TET10", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 J2 bounded evidence", "historical modal/dynamic tests", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 bounded Euler and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. No nonlinear collapse claim; 0.2.6 maturity extension is pending.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "nonlinear_load_control", "capability_id": "COMB-TET10-nonlinear_load_control", "element_family": "TET10", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 J2 bounded evidence", "historical modal/dynamic tests", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 nonlinear owner evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Maturity extension and multi-family correlation are scheduled separately.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX8-linear_static", "element_family": "HEX8", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX8 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 regression and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Family-specific requalification is scheduled in G04.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX8-modal", "element_family": "HEX8", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX8 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: modal evidence covers eight internal family rows, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "newmark_transient", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX8-newmark_transient", "element_family": "HEX8", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX8 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: Newmark refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "harmonic", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX8-harmonic", "element_family": "HEX8", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX8 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: harmonic refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_buckling", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX8-linear_buckling", "element_family": "HEX8", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "EXPERIMENTAL does not mean QUALIFIED_BOUNDED, normal-use or production-ready.", "No general Euler prediction or convergence claim is made; WP06/WP06B Euler and convergence FAIL records remain visible.", "No certification, imperfections, nonlinear/post-buckling, plasticity, arbitrary-mesh, universal-accuracy, multi-mode or mixed-mesh claim.", "No external correlation claim; current comparable Code_Aster/CalculiX evidence was unavailable.", "HEX8R, SRI, B-bar and hourglass formulations are excluded." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_EXPERIMENTAL", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp11b_hex8_buckling_owner_gate_final.json", "resulting_maturity": "EXPERIMENTAL", "scope": "HEX8 linear eigenvalue buckling; linear-elastic prestress; valid bounded cantilever geometries; explicitly tested clamped solid-block boundary condition; first positive mode; exploratory/research use only.", "transition": "COMB-HEX8-linear_buckling: NOT_QUALIFIED -> EXPERIMENTAL", "work_package": "WP11B" } ], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "NOT_QUALIFIED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX8 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 bounded Euler and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "G14 explicitly retains HEX8 buckling as more-evidence-required. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. No nonlinear collapse claim; 0.2.6 maturity extension is pending.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_G14_MORE_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" }, { "analysis": "nonlinear_load_control", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX8-nonlinear_load_control", "element_family": "HEX8", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX8 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 nonlinear owner evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Maturity extension and multi-family correlation are scheduled separately.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX20-linear_static", "element_family": "HEX20", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX20 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 regression and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Family-specific requalification is scheduled in G04.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX20-modal", "element_family": "HEX20", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX20 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: modal evidence covers eight internal family rows, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "newmark_transient", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX20-newmark_transient", "element_family": "HEX20", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX20 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: Newmark refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "harmonic", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX20-harmonic", "element_family": "HEX20", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX20 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: harmonic refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_buckling", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX20-linear_buckling", "element_family": "HEX20", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX20 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 bounded Euler and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. No nonlinear collapse claim; 0.2.6 maturity extension is pending.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "nonlinear_load_control", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX20-nonlinear_load_control", "element_family": "HEX20", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX20 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 nonlinear owner evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Maturity extension and multi-family correlation are scheduled separately.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "geometric_nonlinear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-TET4-geometric_nonlinear_static", "element_family": "TET4", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 owner evidence", "0.2.6 G05-B TET4 cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 G02 bounded Total-Lagrangian evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS; external coverage is bounded and other analysis scopes remain separately governed. Only bounded TET4/HEX8 Total-Lagrangian elasticity is qualified; high-order and finite-kinematic J2 remain non-qualified.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "geometric_nonlinear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-TET10-geometric_nonlinear_static", "element_family": "TET10", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 J2 bounded evidence", "historical modal/dynamic tests", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 G02 bounded Total-Lagrangian evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Only bounded TET4/HEX8 Total-Lagrangian elasticity is qualified; high-order and finite-kinematic J2 remain non-qualified.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "geometric_nonlinear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX8-geometric_nonlinear_static", "element_family": "HEX8", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX8 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 G02 bounded Total-Lagrangian evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Only bounded TET4/HEX8 Total-Lagrangian elasticity is qualified; high-order and finite-kinematic J2 remain non-qualified.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "geometric_nonlinear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-HEX20-geometric_nonlinear_static", "element_family": "HEX20", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.5 HEX20 evidence", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 G02 bounded Total-Lagrangian evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 internal quantitative and analytical evidence is present; comparable independent external deck remains pending. Only bounded TET4/HEX8 Total-Lagrangian elasticity is qualified; high-order and finite-kinematic J2 remain non-qualified.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-DISCRETE-linear_static", "element_family": "DISCRETE", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Uncoupled translational linear ground springs and declared assembly invariant only; no rotational, oriented, nonlinear, gap or coupled claim." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP03" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 shell_beam_discrete planned cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "0.2.5 regression and external evidence" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 modal/dynamic/harmonic coverage is bounded; other discrete scopes remain governed by their own gates. Family-specific requalification is scheduled in G04.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-DISCRETE-modal", "element_family": "DISCRETE", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Uncoupled translational spring-mass modes only; no rotational inertia, coupling, damping or transient claim." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP03" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 shell_beam_discrete planned cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 modal/dynamic/harmonic coverage is bounded; other discrete scopes remain governed by their own gates. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: modal evidence covers eight internal family rows, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "newmark_transient", "capability_id": "COMB-DISCRETE-newmark_transient", "element_family": "DISCRETE", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "The gate and coarse time grid are retained unchanged. No promotion is authorized." ], "owner_decision": "REJECT", "promotion_applied": false, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": "coarse.max_phase_error_rad", "resulting_maturity": "EXPERIMENTAL", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP03" } ], "qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 shell_beam_discrete planned cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 modal/dynamic/harmonic coverage is bounded; other discrete scopes remain governed by their own gates. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: Newmark refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "harmonic", "capability_id": "COMB-DISCRETE-harmonic", "element_family": "DISCRETE", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "Damped translational SDOF response on the declared seven-point frequency grid only; no general MDOF or alternate damping-model FRF claim." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": null, "work_package": "WP03" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "0.2.6 shell_beam_discrete planned cases", "0.2.6 G05 final evidence", "g05_requirements.json", "g05_deep_case_registry.json", "0_2_6_g05_final_evidence.md" ], "source_limitations": "Combination state is inherited from aggregate 0.2.6 records; no new execution evidence is implied. G05 modal/dynamic/harmonic coverage is bounded; other discrete scopes remain governed by their own gates. G05 is PASS_WITH_LIMITATIONS: harmonic refinement and analytical evidence are complete, while external correlation remains bounded and family-incomplete.", "source_owner_decision": "INHERITED_0_2_6_SCOPE" }, { "analysis": "linear_static", "capability_id": "COMB-WEDGE6-linear_static", "element_family": "WEDGE6", "owner_decisions": [ { "limitations": [ "No modal, Newmark or harmonic promotion is implied.", "No nonlinear, J2, Total-Lagrangian, contact, WEDGE15, mixed-mesh or unbounded arbitrary-distortion claim is made.", "Automatic orientation repair is not claimed; coincident, nonfinite, inverted, wrong-order and negative-Jacobian geometry must fail explicitly.", "The external correlation claim is limited to the recorded Code_Aster PENTA6 primary observables and declared tolerance classes." ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "promotion_applied": true, "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp05_owner_gate_final.json", "rejected_gate": null, "resulting_maturity": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "scope": "Gmsh Prism 6 WEDGE6, homogeneous isotropic small-strain linear elasticity, linear static analysis, declared nodal/body/gravity/TRI3-pressure/QUAD4-pressure/surface-traction loads, conforming prism assemblies, declared valid distortions and explicit failure of invalid geometry, with displacement, Gauss-point strain/stress, energy, reactions and global equilibrium checks.", "work_package": "WP05" } ], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "EXPERIMENTAL", "source_evidence_refs": [ "qualification/0_2_7/wp07_state.json", "docs/verification/0_2_7/0_2_7_wedge6_kernel.md", "qualification/0_2_7/wp08_state.json", "qualification/0_2_7/vnv_v2/wp08_cases.json", "qualification/0_2_7/vnv_v2/wp08_evidence.json", "tests/integration/test_wedge6_static_workflow.py", "docs/verification/0_2_7/0_2_7_wedge6_static_vertical_slice.md" ], "source_limitations": "WP08 validates the bounded Gmsh Prism 6 static workflow, declared TRI3/QUAD4 face loads, reactions/equilibrium and Gauss-point post-processing; WEDGE6 remains EXPERIMENTAL and public qualification, robustness, modal/dynamic routes, nonlinear routes and external correlation remain deferred.", "source_owner_decision": "WP08_STATIC_VERTICAL_SLICE_EXPERIMENTAL" }, { "analysis": "modal", "capability_id": "COMB-WEDGE6-modal", "element_family": "WEDGE6", "owner_decisions": [], "qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_0_2_7_qualification_state": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "source_evidence_refs": [ "qualification/0_2_7/wp10_final_state.json", "qualification/0_2_7/vnv_v2/wp10_final_cases.json", "qualification/0_2_7/vnv_v2/wp10_final_evidence.json", "docs/verification/0_2_7/0_2_7_wedge6_modal.md", "src/solveur/verification/modal_comparison.py", "tests/unit/test_wp10_final_modal.py", "tests/unit/test_wp10_wedge6_modal.py" ], "source_limitations": "WP10 qualifies only the homogeneous isotropic small-strain WEDGE6 consistent-mass modal route within the declared four-level first-three-mode refinement and four same-mesh Code_Aster PENTA6 comparisons. Modes four to six remain diagnostic for refinement; static evidence is not transferred automatically, and Newmark, harmonic, nonlinear, J2, TL and contact routes remain outside this record.", "source_owner_decision": "OWNER_APPROVED_BOUNDED_FIRST_THREE_MODES" } ], "state_counts": { "EXPERIMENTAL": 14, "NOT_QUALIFIED": 0, "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED": 32 }, "total": 46 }, "internal_research_kernels": [ { "element_family": "PYRAMID5", "public_registered": false, "reason": "bounded internal feasibility only; public dispatch remains fail-closed", "record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp09_pyramid5_matrix.json", "status": "FEASIBLE_CONTINUE" } ], "owner_records_preserved": [ "qualification/0_2_8/wp03_owner_gate_final.json", "qualification/0_2_8/wp04_owner_gate_final.json", "qualification/0_2_8/wp05_owner_gate_final.json", "qualification/0_2_8/wp11b_hex8_buckling_owner_gate_final.json", "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_03d_mixed_mpc_owner_delivery.json" ], "registry_id": "QF-028-CONSOLIDATED-CAPABILITY-REGISTRY", "schema_version": 1, "separate_workflows": [ { "id": "MIXED-TET4-WEDGE6-HEX8-linear_static", "limitations": [ "The affine manufactured solution with equivalent K*u loads is sufficient for the declared assembly/interface/load consistency contract, but is not an independent general mechanical benchmark.", "The refinement sequence demonstrates affine consistency only; it is not a general accuracy-convergence claim.", "No external Code_Aster/CalculiX mixed-family correlation is claimed.", "No modal, Newmark, harmonic, nonlinear, contact, hanging-node, MPC, nonconforming-interface, TET10/HEX20, PYRAMID5 or large-model claim is made." ], "owner_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp07_owner_gate_final.json", "record_kind": "mixed_workflow_qualification", "scope": "linear_static only; TET4, WEDGE6 and HEX8; conforming shared-node triangular and quadrilateral interfaces; small-strain homogeneous isotropic elasticity; valid element geometries; and the nodal, body-force, pressure and surface-traction routes actually exercised by WP07.", "status": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED" }, { "id": "MIXED-TET4-WEDGE6-HEX8-modal", "limitations": [ "The result is a bounded workflow qualification for the tested fixed-base chain, not a universal mixed-modal or all-frequency claim.", "The WP08B contract uses shape-function field prolongation with no extrapolation and a fine consistent-mass inner product; the original WP08 shared-node MAC gate of 0.5 remains unchanged and its 0.1028 failure remains historical evidence.", "The independent dense local-matrix scatter/eigensolve plus analytical mass conservation is sufficient for the declared assembly scope; no external industrial-solver correlation is claimed.", "No modal stress, lumped/concentrated mass, Newmark, harmonic, nonlinear, contact, nonconforming/hanging-node/MPC/RBE interface, TET10/HEX20, PYRAMID5, large-model performance or universal all-frequency claim is made." ], "owner_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp08b_owner_gate_final.json", "record_kind": "mixed_workflow_qualification", "scope": "modal linear only; fixed x=0 base; conforming shared-node triangular and quadrilateral interfaces; TET4, WEDGE6 and HEX8; small-strain homogeneous isotropic elasticity; consistent translational finite-element mass; first six positive modes; refinement levels 1, 2, 4 and 8; and valid geometries in the already qualified elementary domains.", "status": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED" }, { "evidence_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp09_pyramid5_vnv.json", "id": "PYRAMID5-feasibility", "limitations": [ "The collapsed-coordinate Jacobian and derivatives are singular at the apex, which is never a derivative or quadrature point.", "No coherent conforming PYRAMID5 h-refinement, convergence claim or external-solver correlation exists in WP09.", "PYRAMID5 remains absent from the public compatibility descriptor and 0.2.7 capability registry; public solve dispatch remains fail-closed.", "No modal, Newmark, harmonic, nonlinear, contact, SRI, stabilization, hourglass-control, nonconforming, hanging-node, MPC/RBE, PYRAMID13 or general transition-mesh claim is made.", "The separate WP07/WP08 mixed-workflow records are unchanged." ], "owner_record": null, "record_kind": "internal_feasibility_kernel", "scope": "Internal linear-static feasibility kernel only: homogeneous isotropic small-strain elasticity; convex planar QUAD4 base; non-coplanar apex; positive sampled Jacobians; nodal/body/gravity/pressure/surface-traction loads; and the tested conforming HEX8/PYRAMID5/TET4 patch.", "status": "FEASIBLE_CONTINUE" }, { "id": "HEX8-SRI-linear_static", "limitations": [ "No production-use claim.", "No universal incompressibility or universal locking-cure claim.", "No general affine patch-force qualification.", "No arbitrary-distortion, nonlinear, dynamic, contact, HEX8R or hourglass-control scope.", "No external correlation claim." ], "owner_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp10_hex8_sri_owner_gate_final.json", "record_kind": "separate_experimental_capability", "scope": "HEX8-SRI; linear static only; isotropic small-strain elasticity; structured bending cases in the executed domain; documented locking reduction only.", "status": "EXPERIMENTAL_BOUNDED" }, { "id": "MIXED-TET4-WEDGE6-HEX8-large-linear_static", "limitations": [ "The mandatory evidence is a repeated conforming-chain scale model, not an arbitrary connected industrial mesh.", "Runtime and memory are environment records, not universal thresholds.", "No accuracy, production, precision, modal, dynamic, nonlinear or universal scalability claim.", "No PYRAMID5 or HEX8-SRI appears in this large model.", "No external correlation is claimed." ], "owner_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp11_mixed_large_matrix.json", "record_kind": "bounded_performance_evidence", "scope": { "components": 9091, "conforming_interfaces": { "quadrilateral_wedge6_hex8": 9091, "triangular_tet4_wedge6": 9091 }, "dof": 300003, "elements": 27273, "elements_by_family": { "HEX8": 9091, "TET4": 9091, "WEDGE6": 9091 }, "load": "unit total Z load per repeated chain; x=0 DOFs fixed", "nodes": 100001 }, "status": "PASS_WITH_BOUNDED_EVIDENCE" }, { "id": "HEX8-linear_buckling-experimental", "limitations": [ "EXPERIMENTAL does not mean QUALIFIED_BOUNDED, normal-use or production-ready.", "No general Euler prediction or convergence claim is made; WP06/WP06B Euler and convergence FAIL records remain visible.", "No certification, imperfections, nonlinear/post-buckling, plasticity, arbitrary-mesh, universal-accuracy, multi-mode or mixed-mesh claim.", "No external correlation claim; current comparable Code_Aster/CalculiX evidence was unavailable.", "HEX8R, SRI, B-bar and hourglass formulations are excluded." ], "owner_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp11b_hex8_buckling_owner_gate_final.json", "record_kind": "experimental_capability", "scope": "HEX8 linear eigenvalue buckling; linear-elastic prestress; valid bounded cantilever geometries; explicitly tested clamped solid-block boundary condition; first positive mode; exploratory/research use only.", "status": "EXPERIMENTAL" }, { "evidence_references": { "owner_gate": { "source": "WP13-03C Owner Gate audited at 5e48f259d1adbed42c1f0ec3851b14bb35df0c0a", "status": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS" }, "v1": { "contract_id": "WP13-03-MIXED-MPC-RBE2-001", "contract_status": "BLOCKED_INVALID_TET4_ORIENTATION", "path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_03a_mixed_mpc_rbe2_contract.json", "sha256": "9ef7113c45a0bf285d532bd64cbfe22193edaee333bb3cb698e54d40c0785e06", "status": "preserved" }, "v2": { "contract_id": "WP13-03-MIXED-MPC-RBE2-002", "contract_status": "FAIL_ENERGY", "path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_03a_mixed_mpc_rbe2_contract_v2.json", "sha256": "10ff2f0708c4f579c7a032036d981f616e8970f04ee000ed86b9146d3ca903d7", "status": "preserved" }, "v3": { "contract_id": "WP13-03-MIXED-MPC-RBE2-003", "contract_path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_03b_v3_mpc_rbe2_contract.json", "contract_sha256": "0d43ef67274ef7675cc643e722b4647da9d66c774f46339c23135ac8d514d44a", "evidence_path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_03b_v3_mpc_rbe2_runtime/wp13_03b_v3_evidence.json", "evidence_sha256": "811149532f5bd1561a72455104ccb40f2d5a2435adafe092d50bcb1965e4b7e9", "raw_npz_path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_03b_v3_mpc_rbe2_runtime/wp13_03b_v3_raw.npz", "raw_npz_sha256": "22bcc6ecfbb0d53681cc0368767793a6dfe2370ca55d57d277f32baeaceb0cef", "status": "successful_prospective_campaign" } }, "id": "MIXED-TET4-WEDGE6-HEX8-linear_static_translational_mpc", "limitations": [ "linear static only", "connected conforming TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8", "translational MPC only", "homogeneous constraints", "zero affine offset", "no rotational RBE2", "no true rigid-body claim", "no RBE3", "no modal MPC", "no Newmark MPC", "no harmonic MPC", "no nonlinear MPC", "no contact coupling", "no nonconforming interfaces", "no arbitrary MPC claim", "no universal claim" ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "owner_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_03d_mixed_mpc_owner_delivery.json", "public_wording": "Connected conforming TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8 mixed linear-static workflow validated with translational linear MPC constraints generated from the frozen RBE2-definition benchmark.", "record_kind": "mixed_workflow_qualification", "scope": "Connected conforming TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8 linear-static workflow with homogeneous zero-offset translational linear MPC constraints generated from the frozen RBE2-definition benchmark.", "status": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "workflow": "mixed_linear_static_translational_mpc" }, { "evidence_references": { "owner_gate": { "source": "WP13-04C Owner Gate audited at e52a116df1f4f5d458bbf71915f94296551c213a", "status": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS" }, "contract": { "contract_id": "WP13-04-MIXED-MULTIMATERIAL-001", "path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_04_multimaterial_contract.json", "sha256": "6bcea1571ba794a3069d8f2d28a49ead2f451b39082a186b54b481d7bab053dc" }, "campaign": { "evidence_path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_04_multimaterial_runtime_final/wp13_04_multimaterial_evidence.json", "report_path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_04_multimaterial_runtime_final/wp13_04_multimaterial_report.json", "raw_npz_path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_04_multimaterial_runtime_final/wp13_04_multimaterial_arrays.npz" } }, "id": "MIXED-TET4-WEDGE6-HEX8-linear_static_multimaterial", "limitations": [ "linear static only", "connected conforming TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8", "isotropic linear-elastic materials only", "multiple material regions", "perfectly bonded shared-node interfaces", "tested Gmsh region-to-material mapping", "tested bounded material contrasts only", "no nonlinear materials", "no plasticity", "no anisotropy", "no contact", "no nonconforming interfaces", "no modal", "no Newmark", "no harmonic", "no arbitrary material contrasts", "no arbitrary meshes", "no general convergence claim", "no universal claim" ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_WITH_LIMITATIONS", "owner_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_04d_multimaterial_owner_delivery.json", "public_wording": "Connected conforming TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8 linear-static workflow with multiple isotropic linear-elastic material regions and perfectly bonded shared-node interfaces within the documented scope.", "record_kind": "mixed_workflow_qualification", "refinement_status": "CHARACTERIZATION_ONLY", "scope": "Connected conforming TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8 linear-static models with multiple isotropic linear-elastic material regions and perfectly bonded shared-node interfaces within the documented scope.", "status": "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED", "workflow": "mixed_linear_static_multimaterial" }, { "delivery_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_02d_mixed_dynamics_delivery.json", "evidence_references": { "manifest": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_02_mixed_dynamics_vnv/final/manifest.json", "raw_npz": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_02_mixed_dynamics_vnv/final/wp13_02_mixed_dynamics_arrays.npz", "archive_sha256": "141016b969838350bb0099fe0af7f861265cfd58065b632be9d434489d692c48", "raw_arrays": 119, "semantic_digest": "7ab0dc50a9ef1872f26d0a0dd16935faa57e4728d76858aa88b998307f0b2d38", "failure_cases": "10/10 PASS", "replays": "Newmark 2/2 PASS" }, "id": "MIXED-TET4-WEDGE6-HEX8-NEWMARK-LINEAR", "limitations": [ "serial only", "linear only", "TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8 only", "documented Rayleigh damping only", "gamma=0.5 beta=0.25 tested scope", "T1/160 only as acceptance", "T1/40 and T1/80 remain characterization", "no universal timestep convergence", "no arbitrary damping", "no nonlinear dynamics", "no contact dynamics", "no impact", "no MPI/distributed dynamics" ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_EXPERIMENTAL_BOUNDED", "owner_gate_source": "WP13-02C Owner Gate audited at bd8bec5f942ddaf4d5b60823f721ad7599e50ebf", "public_wording": "Experimental bounded mixed TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8 Newmark linear dynamics within the documented timestep, damping, loading and model scope.", "record_kind": "mixed_workflow_capability", "scope": "connected serial TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8; linear dynamics; Newmark gamma=0.5 beta=0.25; documented Rayleigh mass-proportional damping; documented half-sine load; T1/160 acceptance scope", "status": "EXPERIMENTAL_BOUNDED", "contract": { "id": "WP13-02-MIXED-DYNAMICS-001", "sha256": "27705f5218a5adc5c929ef26794a2d6ded9024aff8f7d6f52b0601525f8d1f1f", "path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_02_mixed_dynamics_contract.json" }, "workflow": "mixed_tet4_wedge6_hex8_newmark_linear" }, { "delivery_record": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_02d_mixed_dynamics_delivery.json", "evidence_references": { "manifest": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_02_mixed_dynamics_vnv/final/manifest.json", "raw_npz": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_02_mixed_dynamics_vnv/final/wp13_02_mixed_dynamics_arrays.npz", "archive_sha256": "141016b969838350bb0099fe0af7f861265cfd58065b632be9d434489d692c48", "raw_arrays": 119, "semantic_digest": "7ab0dc50a9ef1872f26d0a0dd16935faa57e4728d76858aa88b998307f0b2d38", "failure_cases": "10/10 PASS", "replays": "Harmonic 2/2 PASS" }, "id": "MIXED-TET4-WEDGE6-HEX8-HARMONIC-LINEAR", "limitations": [ "serial only", "linear only", "TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8 only", "documented damping only", "frozen tested sweep only", "no arbitrary frequency range claim", "no universal resonance prediction", "no nonlinear response", "no contact", "no MPI", "no modal-reduction claim" ], "owner_decision": "APPROVE_EXPERIMENTAL_BOUNDED", "owner_gate_source": "WP13-02C Owner Gate audited at bd8bec5f942ddaf4d5b60823f721ad7599e50ebf", "public_wording": "Experimental bounded mixed TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8 harmonic linear response within the documented frequency, damping, loading and model scope.", "record_kind": "mixed_workflow_capability", "scope": "connected serial TET4/WEDGE6/HEX8; linear harmonic response; documented Rayleigh damping; frozen 12-frequency sweep from 0 to 2*f1; documented load/support/model scope", "status": "EXPERIMENTAL_BOUNDED", "contract": { "id": "WP13-02-MIXED-DYNAMICS-001", "sha256": "27705f5218a5adc5c929ef26794a2d6ded9024aff8f7d6f52b0601525f8d1f1f", "path": "qualification/0_2_8/wp13_02_mixed_dynamics_contract.json" }, "workflow": "mixed_tet4_wedge6_hex8_harmonic_linear" } ], "source_registry": "qualification/0_2_7/capability_registry_v2.json", "source_registry_sha256": "cea5cbc24f6c28b22903d7cbfe76aab83ae654e7029d5604f07937fb7f5d1b48", "source_registry_state": { "EXPERIMENTAL": 25, "NOT_QUALIFIED": 1, "QUALIFIED_BOUNDED": 20, "TOTAL": 46 } }